Plagiarism Screening Policy

JCMID is committed to upholding the highest standards of originality and academic integrity in every manuscript we publish.

Overview

JCMID uses iThenticate / Turnitin to screen all submitted manuscripts for textual similarity prior to peer review. The screening is applied to the full manuscript text, excluding references, directly quoted text, and bibliography.

Similarity threshold: Manuscripts with an overall similarity index above 20% (excluding references, quoted text, and bibliography) will be returned to the authors before the review process begins.

Note: A similarity score alone is not conclusive evidence of plagiarism. The editorial team applies judgment to the full context of each report before any decision is made.

Types of Plagiarism

01

Verbatim Copying

Reproducing another author's text word-for-word without the use of quotation marks or proper attribution to the original source.

02

Paraphrasing Plagiarism

Restating another person's ideas, arguments, or findings in different words without providing appropriate credit to the original author.

03

Self-Plagiarism / Duplicate Publication

Reusing substantial portions of one's own previously published text, data, or figures without disclosure and appropriate citation of the prior work.

04

Data Fabrication & Falsification

Inventing research data, results, or experimental outcomes that were never gathered, or manipulating existing data to misrepresent findings.

05

Mosaic Plagiarism

Patchwriting — borrowing phrases, sentences, or ideas from multiple sources and combining them into a new text without credit to any of the originals.

Screening Process

1

Initial Submission Check

Every manuscript undergoes plagiarism screening immediately upon submission, before it is assigned to an editor or sent for peer review.

2

Editorial Review of Report

The similarity report is reviewed in full by the editorial team. Matched sources are assessed individually — context, intent, and nature of overlap are all considered before any conclusion is drawn.

3

Author Notification

If the similarity index exceeds the threshold, or if the editorial team identifies a concern regardless of score, authors are notified with a copy of the report and an explanation of the issue found.

4

Re-Screening of Revised Manuscripts

Manuscripts returned to authors for similarity concerns are re-screened upon resubmission. The revised manuscript must meet the required threshold before it proceeds to peer review.

Consequences

MINOR <20%, isolated overlap

Authors are asked to revise citations and attribution in the affected sections. The manuscript is returned for correction before proceeding to review.

MODERATE 20–40% similarity

The manuscript is returned to the authors. A major revision addressing all similarity concerns is required before the submission can be reconsidered for review.

SEVERE >40% or intentional

Immediate rejection. The authors' institution is notified. Authors may be banned from submitting to JCMID for a period determined by the editorial board.

Retrospective Screening

All published articles may be re-screened retrospectively. If plagiarism is detected in a published article, JCMID will initiate retraction procedures in accordance with COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) guidelines. Authors, editors, and reviewers are all subject to this policy.

Questions About This Policy?

Authors and institutions with questions about the plagiarism screening policy or a specific screening result are encouraged to contact the editorial office directly.

editorial@jcmid.id

Journal of Clinical Microbiology and Infectious Diseases (JCMID)  ·  jcmid.id  ·  Policy effective from current volume