Generative AI Policy
JCMID recognises the rapid development of generative AI tools and their significant impact on academic publishing. This standalone policy governs the use of AI by authors, reviewers, and editors involved with this journal.
This policy is aligned with COPE (2023) and ICMJE (2023) guidelines on AI in scholarly publishing and will be updated as standards evolve.
AI tools do not meet ICMJE authorship criteria, which require accountability and responsibility for the work. Listing an AI tool as an author or co-author is grounds for immediate rejection.
All use of AI in manuscript preparation must be disclosed in the Methods section or Acknowledgements. Non-disclosure constitutes a breach of publication ethics and may result in retraction.
The corresponding author bears full responsibility for all AI-assisted content, including its accuracy, integrity, originality, and any errors or hallucinations introduced by AI tools.
The following AI uses are permitted, provided they are disclosed:
- Grammar and spelling correction of author-written text
- Language polishing and translation assistance
- Reorganising or restructuring author-generated content
- Literature search assistance (with independent verification of all sources)
- Statistical software and bioinformatics tools (cite the tool name and version)
The following uses are prohibited and constitute research misconduct:
- Generating original research data, results, or scientific conclusions
- Writing Methods, Results, or Discussion sections without substantive human authorship
- Fabricating or hallucinating references, citations, or supporting evidence
- Generating figures or clinical images without explicit disclosure in the figure legend
- Submitting AI-generated text as original, human-authored work
Authors must include a disclosure statement in their manuscript. Example:
“The authors used [tool name, version] for [specific purpose, e.g., grammar checking]. The authors reviewed and verified all AI-assisted content and take full responsibility for the integrity of this work.”
Reviewers must NOT input any manuscript text into an AI tool. Doing so violates confidentiality obligations and the peer review agreement.
AI may be used only for general language assistance when writing the review itself — not for content analysis of the submitted manuscript.
Editors may use AI tools for routine editorial tasks such as scheduling, analytics, and correspondence drafting.
Editors must not use AI to make accept/reject decisions. All editorial decisions require informed human judgment.
- AI-generated figures or images must be explicitly disclosed in the figure legend.
- AI-generated images must not misrepresent biological structures, clinical findings, or patient data.
- All AI-generated visual content is subject to JCMID's image integrity policy.
- Rejection of the manuscript prior to publication
- Retraction of the article post-publication with public notice
- Formal notification to the author's institution
- Possible ban from future submissions to JCMID
Contact the editorial office for guidance on AI use in your manuscript.
editorial@jcmid.idPolicy aligned with COPE 2023 & ICMJE 2023 guidelines