Manuscript Appeal Policy
Authors who believe their manuscript was rejected due to a misunderstanding, a factual error in the review, or a procedural irregularity may submit a formal appeal to the editorial office.
Appeals are NOT accepted simply because authors disagree with the scientific judgment of reviewers or editors.
The rejection was based on a demonstrable factual inaccuracy in the review — for example, the reviewer misquoted data, made an incorrect claim about methodology, or cited a non-existent limitation.
There is evidence that the peer review process was not followed correctly — for example, a reviewer had an undisclosed conflict of interest, or the manuscript was reviewed outside the stated process.
The review overlooked or fundamentally misunderstood a critical aspect of the manuscript — one that would materially affect the editorial decision if correctly considered.
- General disagreement with the scientific judgment of reviewers or editors
- Submission of new data or a substantially revised manuscript (re-submit as a new submission instead)
- Rejection based on journal scope, thematic priority, or editorial capacity
- General dissatisfaction with the tone or brevity of reviewer comments
Send to editorial@jcmid.id with subject line:
“Appeal — [Manuscript ID] — [Short Title]”
Include the original rejection letter and confirm the manuscript ID in your message.
Provide a clear, point-by-point rebuttal identifying the specific factual error or procedural irregularity.
Appeals must be submitted within 30 days of the date of the rejection decision.
The Editor-in-Chief will review the appeal and may, at their discretion:
- Consult the original reviewers for clarification
- Seek an additional, independent expert opinion
- Review the manuscript personally alongside the appeal submission
The manuscript re-enters the formal peer review process, or the editorial decision is reconsidered directly by the editors on its scientific merits.
An additional independent review is commissioned to supplement or correct the deficient aspect of the original assessment.
The original editorial decision stands. No further appeal is possible for the same manuscript. Authors may resubmit a substantially revised work as a new submission.
- Submitting an appeal does not guarantee reversal of the editorial decision.
- The appeal decision issued by the Editor-in-Chief is final.
- Authors wishing to revise and resubmit should do so as a new submission, not an appeal.
- Appeals submitted beyond the 30-day window will not be considered.
Send your formal appeal to the editorial office within 30 days of rejection.
Subject: Appeal — [Manuscript ID] — [Short Title]
editorial@jcmid.idAppeals handled in accordance with COPE guidelines | jcmid.id