Editorial and Publisher Responsibilities
JCMID operates under a clear framework of editorial independence and publisher accountability, aligned with COPE's Core Practices for Editors and Publishers. The roles and responsibilities of each stakeholder are defined below to ensure transparency, integrity, and consistent quality in all editorial operations.
The editors of JCMID make all acceptance and rejection decisions based solely on scientific merit, originality, ethical standards, and relevance to journal scope — completely free from commercial, institutional, or political influence.
The publisher (Universitas Airlangga / PAMKI) provides financial and technical support for journal operations but does not interfere with any individual editorial decisions. This independence is a non-negotiable condition of publication.
- Final authority on all editorial decisions, including acceptance, rejection, and retraction
- Ensuring the integrity and fairness of the peer review process
- Overseeing full compliance with publication ethics standards
- Leading the editorial board and coordinating section editors
- Handling author appeals and allegations of research misconduct
- Ensuring all journal policies are current, accessible, and publicly available
- Assign manuscripts to appropriately qualified reviewers within their area of expertise
- Make initial editorial recommendations to the Editor-in-Chief
- Manage the revision process, including evaluating author responses
- Ensure timely decisions and communication with authors throughout the review cycle
- Identify, invite, and onboard qualified peer reviewers for submitted manuscripts
- Manage and document conflicts of interest before reviewer assignment
- Maintain strict reviewer confidentiality throughout the review process
- Provide structured feedback and recognition to support reviewer quality and engagement
Editors with a conflict of interest in any submitted manuscript — including co-authorship relationships, institutional affiliations, personal relationships, or competing interests — must recuse themselves immediately and delegate the editorial decision to another qualified editor. All conflicts of interest must be documented and retained for the editorial record.
Authors who believe that an editorial decision was improperly made may submit a formal complaint:
- Complaints about an Associate/Section Editor → contact the Editor-in-Chief
- Complaints about the Editor-in-Chief → contact the Publisher
All complaints are handled in accordance with COPE guidelines. Contact: editorial@jcmid.id
For editorial complaints, appeals, or policy enquiries, contact the editorial office.
editorial@jcmid.idPublished by Universitas Airlangga / PAMKI | COPE Member