COPE · ICMJE · Double-Blind · AI Declaration

Peer Review Process

JCMID applies a rigorous double-blind peer review process to ensure the scientific quality, integrity, and objectivity of all published articles.

Double-Blind Review ≥2 Independent Reviewers COPE Compliant AI Declaration Required

Double-Blind Peer Review

The review process at JCMID is double-blind: neither the reviewer's nor the author's identities are disclosed to the other party at any stage of the process. This ensures objective, unbiased evaluation of each submission based solely on its scientific merit.

Each submission is evaluated by a minimum of two independent expert reviewers with relevant expertise in clinical microbiology and infectious diseases. Final editorial decisions are made by the Editor-in-Chief based on reviewer recommendations, in accordance with COPE and ICMJE guidelines.

Step-by-Step Process

1

Submission & Blinding

Authors must prepare their manuscripts to conceal their identity throughout the double-blind review process. Submit two separate files via the OJS submission portal:

File 1 — Title Page

  • Full article title
  • All author names, affiliations, and ORCID iDs
  • Corresponding author's address, phone, and email
  • Author contributions (CRediT taxonomy)
  • Conflict of interest declaration
  • Funding sources
  • Acknowledgements

File 2 — Blinded Manuscript

  • No author names or affiliations anywhere
  • No acknowledgements or funding section
  • No institutional identifiers in figures or tables
  • Anonymous file name (no author initials)
  • Document metadata cleared of author information
  • Continuous line numbering from title to references

Self-Reference Blinding Rules

  • Refer to your own prior work in the third person — instead of "as we demonstrated," write "... has been demonstrated [Anonymous, 2022]"
  • In the text, cite your own works as: [Anonymous, year]
  • In the reference list: [Anonymous year] Information withheld for double-blind review
  • Include only self-references that are essential for understanding the current work
2

Initial Evaluation by Editor (1–3 Days)

Every submission undergoes an initial editorial assessment before external review. Manuscripts not passing this stage are returned without review. The evaluation covers:

Scope & Aims Fit English Language Quality Manuscript Structure Ethics & IRB Statement Plagiarism Screening (Turnitin) Blinding Compliance Reporting Guideline Checklist Mandatory Forms Submitted
3

External Peer Review (4–6 Weeks)

Manuscripts passing the initial check are assigned to a minimum of two independent external reviewers with expertise in the relevant field (clinical microbiology, infectious diseases, AMR, virology, parasitology, etc.). Reviewers assess scientific rigor, originality, methodology, statistical appropriateness, data interpretation, and the validity of conclusions.

Reviewer Resources & Checklists

Reviewers are encouraged to use structured checklists appropriate to the manuscript type (CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA, CARE, STARD, ORION). The following resources are provided:

Possible Review Outcomes

Accept

Ready for editorial processing

Minor Revisions

Author responds within 14 days

Major Revisions

Full re-review required

Reject

Does not meet JCMID standards

Authors have 14 days to submit a point-by-point response to reviewer comments and resubmit their revised manuscript. The assigned reviewer will re-evaluate the revision before making a final recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief.

4

Editorial Procedure & Publication

Accepted manuscripts are forwarded to the Editor-in-Chief for final copyediting and proofreading. Authors must review and approve the final galley proof before publication. Minor editorial corrections may be incorporated at this stage. A DOI is assigned upon acceptance.

Final Copyediting Galley Proof Approval DOI Assignment (CrossRef) PDF Galley Production Open-Access Publication Indexing & Archiving
 

COPE 2023 · ICMJE · Updated Policy

AI Use & Declaration in Peer Review

For Reviewers

✓ Permitted Uses

  • Grammar and language checking of the review text
  • Literature search assistance to locate relevant references
  • Formatting or structuring reviewer comments
  • Translation assistance (reviewer must verify accuracy)

✗ Not Permitted

  • Using AI to write or generate the review report
  • Uploading any part of the manuscript to any AI tool
  • Using AI to formulate the Accept/Reject recommendation
  • Submitting AI-generated review text without disclosure
  • Using AI to assess statistical methods without expert oversight

⚠ Confidentiality Warning

Reviewers must never upload any part of the submitted manuscript to a public AI tool (ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Claude, DeepSeek, or any similar platform). Submitted manuscripts are strictly confidential documents. Uploading them to any external platform constitutes a serious breach of the peer review agreement and COPE guidelines, and may result in permanent removal from the JCMID reviewer panel and a formal complaint to the reviewer's institution.

Mandatory AI Disclosure for Reviewers

If AI tools were used in any permitted capacity, reviewers must disclose this in the "Confidential Comments to the Editor" field, stating:

  • Name and version of the AI tool used
  • Specific purpose (e.g., "Used Grammarly for grammar checking of review text only")
  • Explicit confirmation that no manuscript content was uploaded to the tool

For Authors — AI Declaration in Submitted Manuscripts

Authors who used any AI tool during manuscript preparation must declare this clearly. The declaration must appear in the Methods section (for AI used in research-related tasks) or the Acknowledgements (for language editing or formatting). The declaration must specify:

Tool Name & Version

e.g., ChatGPT-4o (OpenAI), Grammarly Pro

Purpose of Use

Specific task performed

Section Where Used

Which part of the manuscript

Example Declaration

"The authors used Grammarly (v. 2024) for grammar and spelling corrections of the final manuscript draft. ChatGPT-4o (OpenAI) was used to assist with English language editing of the Introduction section. The scientific content, microbiological data, methodology, and conclusions are solely the authors' responsibility. No AI-generated text was included without review and verification by the corresponding author."

Important: AI tools cannot be listed as co-authors under any circumstances. The corresponding author is fully accountable for all content in the manuscript, including AI-assisted portions. Undisclosed AI use constitutes a breach of publication ethics and may result in rejection, retraction, or a permanent submission ban.

Indicative Timeline

1–3

Days

Initial editorial screening

4–6

Weeks

External peer review

14

Days

Author revision window

1–2

Weeks

Editorial & production

Governed By

COPE ICMJE Double-Blind Review COPE AI Position 2023 Turnitin Declaration of Helsinki WAME EQUATOR Network